I publish examples of foolishness, laziness, stupidity, and sin in the vast world of online marketing. First, there is the entertainment value. Second, there is the instructive value. Each post must address both values to make it online.
No. As much as possible, I like to divorce the examples from people.
First, no one would read the blog otherwise. Second, I believe that by viewing abject examples of online marketing, it is possible for the intelligent online marketer to achieve greater success. You will note that each post comes with a positive takeway for success. There is no point in viewing negative examples if you cannot get something positive out of it.
No one, and I do not claim to be an authority. I am learning every day.
Point well taken. And if want to level the playing field, below I mention a hideously bad campaign of my own.
Think about this carefully first. First, if you cannot take the criticism, you should be out of the profession. Now consider this:
This blog may piss off some people. They will say, “How are you the authority?” Or, “You’re not so great yourself.”
Instead of answering each person individually, I will point them to this story. It is a story of abject, ignoble failure. It is a story of overwhelming hubris and dumbness. After reading an interview with Rand Fishkin, where he mentions that humility is most important in online marketing, I present to you my story.
In terms of failures, it cuts through all categories. Niches, keywords, domains, PPC, and more—it was just plain stupid.
Numbskull Niche
Apple was having problems with batteries for its Powerbooks catching fire. Being new to internet marketing, I figured: This is new and topical, surely it will bring in tons of traffic to a site devoted exclusively to that one narrow niche. The problem is that it wasn’t even a niche; it was a news item. Sure, if Powerbooks have been catching fire for ten years and there is a local and dedicated audience of readers who care about this…and who will click on related ads…then you’ve got something resembling a niche. Mine was more than a bad nightmare than a niche idea.
Domain Dumbness
So I went to the worst domain registrar and webhost on earth, Dotster, and registered a domain. www.apple-battery-recall.com, created a quick 5 page site with Microsoft FrontPage, threw in some original content, and added those almighty Google AdSense ads.
I published the site and sat back, rubbing my hands together, envisioning the hundreds of thousands of visitors. I figured that even if only 1% off the visitors clicked on an ad, I was set to make a fortune.
Within 30 minutes of publishing my site, I was Googling for “apple battery recall” in hopes of finding my site up there at #1 position.
Yeah, right. This plan was so flawed, it’s even hard to talk about today without a lump in my throat (excuse me while I dab my eyes here…)
Oh wait - I did get one click.
I walked down to our local library, logged onto the Internet there, and click on one of my own Google AdSense ads. I believe I made $0.05 from that. Guilty as charged. Here is the list of charges. Readers will most likely add more charges…with glee.
Not to mention lesser sins and stupidity like using a substandard dying application like Microsoft Frontpage, using a know-nothing company like Dotster, and, and…
The list goes on.
My Success Takeaway
My campaign was to online marketing what a marshmallow is to gourmet food. You can’t ever hope to rehabilitate the marshmallow to make it gourmet: you just throw it away.
Recent Advice from Readers